Heartland: The Fights Are in the Songs

I will only talk about the rooms where they sing. Heartland, which Shana Feste wrote and directed for Netflix, is sold as a mystery: Misty Jones, a retired country star, comes back to Nashville after 20 years because her niece, a rising singer, has vanished. The mystery is the weaker half. Its plot is overstuffed, its early turn announces itself a long way off, and the notices have itemised both. I have nothing to add to that column. What holds me is that the same film, under the same director and the same cinematographer, contains a second film that works, and that the border between the two runs along the lip of the stage. ...

November 14, 20267 minFrançois RivetteAnatomy of the Craft

A Talent for Murder: The Room She Would Not Leave

There are two kinds of film made from a two-character play. The first keeps the door shut: it accepts that the play’s whole asset is pressure, two people and a room with nowhere to go, and it spends its money on faces and light. The second opens the door, because cinema can, and sends the camera out into the country while the pressure leaks quietly through the gap. Anton Corbijn’s A Talent for Murder, adapted by Joanna Murray-Smith from her own 2014 play Switzerland, is built on the border between the two, and the reviews out of Toronto, which disagree about nearly everything else, agree on exactly where it stands: strongest inside the chalet, weaker every time it leaves. ...

October 31, 20267 minFrançois RivetteAnatomy of the Craft

The Only Living Pickpocket in New York: Watch the Hands

I am going to talk about the hands, and let everything else in Noah Segan’s The Only Living Pickpocket in New York follow from them, because that is how the film itself is built. Harry (John Turturro) lifts a wallet and a gym bag from a young man in the opening stretch using, by IGN’s account, only a penny, and IGN goes on to describe the method the film takes care to show us: wallets snatched as if the thief were invisible, overcoats cut with tactical pockets so that the path from removal to hiding place is the shortest possible. The Substack critic John Doc calls these passages process porn, with approval, and he is right to approve; a film that bothers to show you how a trade is actually done has already made a promise about how seriously it will take everything else. Système D as a way of life, filmed with respect. The question is whether the rest of the picture keeps the promise the hands make. ...

October 28, 20267 minFrançois RivetteAnatomy of the Craft

El Mariachi: The Zero-Crew Kinetic Aesthetic

To finance his 1992 debut El Mariachi, Robert Rodriguez did not max out credit cards, nor did he beg for studio money. He literally sold his body to science. He volunteered as a “lab rat” for clinical drug trials, writing much of the script while confined to a medical research facility. He emerged with $7,000 and a radical production plan. The Zero-Crew Model Rodriguez adopted a strict “zero-crew” production model. He did not hire a director of photography, a sound mixer, or an assistant director. He operated as the writer, director, cinematographer, camera operator, sound recordist, and editor simultaneously. He had no crew to set up lights, pull focus, or wrangle cables. ...

April 25, 20242 minFrançois RivetteProduction Mechanics

Following: The Weekend Guerrilla

Before he commanded multi-million dollar budgets and built full-scale IMAX spectacles, Christopher Nolan shot his debut feature Following for just $6,000. He did not have funding, he did not have studio backing, and his cast and crew held full-time jobs during the week. So, Nolan shot the film entirely on Saturdays, stretching the production over the course of an entire year. Available Light and Black-and-White Unable to afford professional lighting equipment, Nolan relied entirely on available light. He staged scenes near windows or utilized practical fixtures already present in the London apartments he borrowed. ...

April 21, 20242 minFrançois RivetteProduction Mechanics

Pi: The Danger of Reversal Film

Most independent filmmakers shooting on a micro-budget opt for standard 16mm negative film. Negative film is forgiving. It maximizes exposure latitude, allowing a nervous director to fix lighting mistakes in post-production. For his $60,000 debut film Pi, Darren Aronofsky and cinematographer Matthew Libatique rejected this safety net. The Unforgiving Stock They made the dangerous, deliberate choice to shoot on 16mm black-and-white reversal film. Unlike negative film, reversal film produces a positive image directly onto the celluloid. It has virtually no dynamic range. This means it is incredibly unforgiving; any slight error in exposure results in a complete loss of detail in the highlights or shadows. If you miss your aperture setting by half a stop, the image is ruined. ...

April 20, 20241 minFrançois RivetteAnatomy of the Craft

Compliance: The Horror of the Breakroom

True horror does not require monsters or jump scares. True horror is found in obedience. To dramatize the horrifying real-world events of a 2004 fast-food “strip search” hoax, director Craig Zobel understood that Compliance could not rely on traditional cinematic tension. The terror had to come from the unbearable pressure of mundane authority. The Architecture of Obedience Zobel confined the narrative almost entirely to the drab, claustrophobic backroom and office of a fictional fast-food restaurant. He traps both his characters and his audience in this high-stress, inescapable environment. Before the psychological abuse even begins, he establishes the chaotic baseline of a minimum-wage workplace: broken freezers, understaffed shifts, and exhausted employees. ...

April 8, 20242 minFrançois RivetteAnatomy of the Craft

Blue Ruin: The Architecture of Debt

The press loves a Cinderella story. When Jeremy Saulnier premiered Blue Ruin at Cannes, the media quickly crowned it the ultimate Kickstarter triumph—a brilliant film entirely crowdsourced by the internet. It is a lovely narrative. It is also a lie. Kickstarter did not finance Blue Ruin. Terror and credit card debt financed Blue Ruin. The Illusion of Crowdfunding The reality of independent financing is far more brutal than a successful marketing campaign. The crowdfunding push accounted for roughly 10% of the film’s $420,000 budget. The true engine of the production was absolute, terrifying personal risk. Saulnier emptied his family’s savings. He refinanced his home. He famously racked up $80,000 in American Express credit card debt. He did not ask the internet for permission to make his film; he forced the film into existence by wagering his own financial ruin. ...

March 29, 20242 minFrançois RivetteThe Business of Independent Film

The Invitation: The Invisible Architecture of Dread

You do not need a haunted castle to make an audience claustrophobic. If you know how to wield a camera and a microphone, a luxurious mid-century modern house in the Hollywood Hills will do just fine. In The Invitation, Karyn Kusama weaponizes domestic architecture to create one of the most suffocating thrillers of the decade. Framing the Trap Because the production could not afford to construct a custom soundstage, Kusama was forced to use an existing house. Instead of treating this as a limitation, she treated the house as a blueprint for dread. ...

March 21, 20242 minFrançois RivetteAnatomy of the Craft

Director's Notebook: Victoria: The Terror of the Single Take

The “single-take” film has become a tedious parlor trick. Directors love to stitch together disparate scenes using hidden cuts and CGI transitions so they can brag to the press about their “unbroken” vision. Sebastian Schipper did not cheat. He enforced a terrifying mechanical constraint: he shot the 138-minute feature film Victoria in one genuinely unbroken take. The Logistics of Exhaustion To achieve this, cinematographer Sturla Brandth Grøvlen had to physically carry a handheld camera through 22 different locations across Berlin. The take began at 4:30 a.m. and ended at 6:48 a.m. This is not just a technical achievement; it is a physical endurance test. The adrenaline and exhaustion you see on the actors’ faces by the end of the film are not performed. They are biologically real. ...

March 20, 20242 minFrançois RivetteDirector's Notebook