Heartland: The Fights Are in the Songs

I will only talk about the rooms where they sing. Heartland, which Shana Feste wrote and directed for Netflix, is sold as a mystery: Misty Jones, a retired country star, comes back to Nashville after 20 years because her niece, a rising singer, has vanished. The mystery is the weaker half. Its plot is overstuffed, its early turn announces itself a long way off, and the notices have itemised both. I have nothing to add to that column. What holds me is that the same film, under the same director and the same cinematographer, contains a second film that works, and that the border between the two runs along the lip of the stage. ...

November 14, 20267 minFrançois RivetteAnatomy of the Craft

Director's Notebook: Block First, Then Light

Lighting a room before the actors have walked it is the dearest hour of the shooting day, and I count it a director’s fault. I have ordered it. What follows is how that order looks from the chair, set down for the gaffers who have to hang the result, because I think it can be argued with, and in front of me it rarely has been. How it looks from the chair The room is ready, the lamps are on the truck, the actors are in makeup, and to a director a crew with nothing in its hands at the top of the morning looks like money leaving. Lighting is the slowest thing the day holds, so he asks the chef op to make a start. The chef op can answer that he does not yet know where the faces will be. Said to a director with the clock in his ear, that sounds like a request for time, and the director believes he is the one offering to save some. ...

November 11, 20265 minFrançois RivetteDirector's NotebookAnatomy of the Craft

A Talent for Murder: The Room She Would Not Leave

There are two kinds of film made from a two-character play. The first keeps the door shut: it accepts that the play’s whole asset is pressure, two people and a room with nowhere to go, and it spends its money on faces and light. The second opens the door, because cinema can, and sends the camera out into the country while the pressure leaks quietly through the gap. Anton Corbijn’s A Talent for Murder, adapted by Joanna Murray-Smith from her own 2014 play Switzerland, is built on the border between the two, and the reviews out of Toronto, which disagree about nearly everything else, agree on exactly where it stands: strongest inside the chalet, weaker every time it leaves. ...

October 31, 20267 minFrançois RivetteAnatomy of the Craft

The Only Living Pickpocket in New York: Watch the Hands

I am going to talk about the hands, and let everything else in Noah Segan’s The Only Living Pickpocket in New York follow from them, because that is how the film itself is built. Harry (John Turturro) lifts a wallet and a gym bag from a young man in the opening stretch using, by IGN’s account, only a penny, and IGN goes on to describe the method the film takes care to show us: wallets snatched as if the thief were invisible, overcoats cut with tactical pockets so that the path from removal to hiding place is the shortest possible. The Substack critic John Doc calls these passages process porn, with approval, and he is right to approve; a film that bothers to show you how a trade is actually done has already made a promise about how seriously it will take everything else. Système D as a way of life, filmed with respect. The question is whether the rest of the picture keeps the promise the hands make. ...

October 28, 20267 minFrançois RivetteAnatomy of the Craft

You Can See Everything: Enough Rope, Patiently Supplied

There are two kinds of access documentary. The first kind extracts: it wins its way into the room and leaves with the confession, the slip, the bombshell the trailer has promised, and its grammar is the ambush, the hard question, the camera held a beat too long on a face that has just lied. The second kind supplies. It gives the subject the room, the time and the silence, and then it films what the subject does with them. You Can See Everything, Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim’s 174-minute documentary about Elizabeth Holmes, belongs with unusual purity to the second kind, and the reviews, which are rapturous to a degree I distrust on principle, agree on this one point even where they disagree on everything else: nobody in this film is cornered. Holmes and her partner Billy Evans, by The Wolfman Cometh’s account, regularly volunteer information Fielder was not seeking. Enough rope, patiently supplied. ...

October 20, 20266 minFrançois RivetteAnatomy of the Craft

The Uprising: A Riot, Documented From Inside

Let me count this one’s debts before its assets, because with Paul Greengrass the two are always drawn from the same account. The debts, filed almost identically by every notice I have read: the middle of The Uprising goes muddled once factions and locations start arriving at speed; several characters function as representations of a class rather than people; and the screenplay keeps reaching past the 1381 Peasants’ Revolt toward folklore, a mythology layer the marketing itself connects to the Robin Hood legend, which sits badly beside the grounded drama around it. Seat42F’s reviewer puts the complaint in one clean sentence, that the film doesn’t need the additional mythology, and Brian Orndorf is blunter still, finding the director dramatically constipated, the pace throttled. The audience wing of the prosecution is on the record too; one r/movies thread opens, with the weariness of a man who paid for his ticket, just watched The Uprising, and honestly, what a slog. ...

October 3, 20265 minFrançois RivetteAnatomy of the Craft

Hot Spot: The Future, Secondhand

The most honest thing in Agnieszka Smoczyńska’s Hot Spot is its real estate. Variety’s reviewer, no admirer of the film’s plotting, still surrendered to what the production design is doing: Anna Anosowicz builds humanity’s last compound out of existing midcentury brutalist architecture and far older ruins, Greek stones included, dressed with what the review calls superficially futuristic window-dressing. The future, in other words, is not built here; it is scavenged. Not a brave new world but a thriftily recycled one, hanging onto past glories by a thread, and that single design decision tells you more about a civilization run by a rationing AI than any title card could. It is also, en passant, the oldest trick of resourceful production: when you cannot afford to build the future, photograph the past strangely enough and the audience will do the rest. Smoczyńska is working with the biggest budget of her career, and she spends it like a director who remembers not having one. ...

September 20, 20265 minFrançois RivetteAnatomy of the Craft

Challengers: The Physics of the Volley

Bref, they told me it was a film about a love triangle. They lied. It is a film about sweat, leverage, and the kinetic violence of an object moving at 130 miles per hour. Luca Guadagnino’s Challengers does not observe a tennis match; it forces you to duck. I browse the public forums and I see the audience arguing. Mon Dieu, it never stops. Half of them are swept away by what they call a “purely pleasurable film,” while the other half complain that they “don’t understand the positive reviews” at all. They argue endlessly about the characters’ morals. They argue about the plot. They miss the point entirely. The brilliance of this film is not found in its narrative; it is found in its physical execution. ...

July 11, 20262 minFrançois RivetteAnatomy of the Craft

Longlegs: Anatomy of a Modern Horror Masterclass

Bref, let us not waste time. We have all seen the numbers. A $22.6 million opening weekend for an independent horror film is not a fluke; it is an earthquake. But while the industry trades hyperventilate over the box office returns of Longlegs, I am far more interested in what Osgood Perkins and his cinematographer, Andres Arochi, actually did on the floor. When you strip away the hype, what remains is an execution so deliberate, so suffocatingly controlled, that it warrants a true post-mortem. This is not a film that succeeded purely because of a flashy ad campaign. It succeeded because the mechanics of its production and the aesthetics of its framing were built to weaponize audience anxiety. ...

September 12, 20244 minFrançois RivetteAnatomy of the Craft

El Mariachi: The Zero-Crew Kinetic Aesthetic

To finance his 1992 debut El Mariachi, Robert Rodriguez did not max out credit cards, nor did he beg for studio money. He literally sold his body to science. He volunteered as a “lab rat” for clinical drug trials, writing much of the script while confined to a medical research facility. He emerged with $7,000 and a radical production plan. The Zero-Crew Model Rodriguez adopted a strict “zero-crew” production model. He did not hire a director of photography, a sound mixer, or an assistant director. He operated as the writer, director, cinematographer, camera operator, sound recordist, and editor simultaneously. He had no crew to set up lights, pull focus, or wrangle cables. ...

April 25, 20242 minFrançois RivetteProduction Mechanics