An American reviewer of Jimmy wrote that its English seaside cliffs “look suspiciously like the oceanside ones in California”. He meant it as a charge of fakery. Aaron Burns shot almost all of his James Stewart film in West Cork, where one corner of Ireland plays Los Angeles, Pennsylvania and the air base at Tibenham in England, so the cliffs that reviewer distrusts are in all likelihood Irish. What interests me is how a company with its office in Los Angeles came to stage the years 1941 to 1945 inside one Irish district, and what that choice did to every department downstream of it.
The studio came first
Burns gives three reasons for the region: the locations, a studio that was available, and the cast and crew he could find there. I would not rank them equally, and I do not think he does either.
Without that studio, we couldn’t have done it, because we had to recreate most of our LA scenes that were in a film studio.
The story begins just after Stewart’s Oscar, and most of its Los Angeles is the inside of a picture factory. So the central location had to be a film studio that could play one, back lot included, and West Cork Film Studios in Skibbereen got the part. Everything else hangs from that. Friends in Ireland had told Burns how much rural Ireland resembles rural England and invited him to look. “We found all the locations we needed there,” he says, and the list runs through Castletownshend, Long Strand Beach, Castlefreke and Bantry House. But scenery is the easy half of a repérage. Any green country will lend you a field and a great house. A stage with a lot behind it, in the same district as the fields, is the rare thing. With a set standing on it, it is also where the day goes when the Atlantic comes in, and a unit that starts on the first of September, as this one did in 2025, will need that.
I have picked a region for its hills and then spent la prépa learning that the nearest stage was a day’s drive away. One does it once.
Ten, ten and 200
By local account this is the largest production West Cork has had, and Burns counts it like this: “We had maybe 10 cast members from America, and probably about the same on crew, and then 200 Irish.” Then the list: “Our director of photography, our production designer, our hair, makeup, wardrobe, our full lighting department, our entire art department, our editor.” Two of the producers were Irish, all of the background was Irish, and the colour and the rest of the post went to a team in Dublin. The crew was based in Skibbereen and beyond, and about twenty people crossed the Atlantic.
The price of hiring this way is that a director far from home has to get 200 people shooting in one manner. Burns’s answer was two rules, and during prep his producer had the second printed on mugs: “What would Capra do?” The first is point of view, “you’re with Jimmy the whole time”, the war seen from inside the cockpit with him. The second is Capra’s manner, carried into “blocking, lighting, camera movement, focus, like even the way the actors stand and interact with each other”. I have directed crews I met a few weeks before the first day, and a rule that fits on a mug is about as much as reaches the floor intact.
The camera carries the plan. In the first half, Burns says, “you can see the background and there’s more space”; then the frame closes on Stewart until “everything else is out of focus”. I pulled focus for a living long before I directed anything, and I know what that asks of the first assistant camera: generous depth for one half of the story, then long glass, an open stop and an actor who will not hold still. And since, in Burns’s own words, “you film everything out of order”, the first AC gets both in the same week.
The first rule also keeps the war at the studios. A real vintage aircraft, a Percival Pembroke adapted for filming, stood there, and a war seen from the cockpit can be shot from inside one. One reviewer who saw an early cut called the flying “visceral and harrowing”; the man with the cliffs blamed “the questionable visual effects used to portray the actor’s missions”. As I read it, the care went inside the fuselage, and whatever lies beyond the glass became a visual effects problem. The second rule splits the room the same way: to one reviewer the gloss of a 1940s Capra picture, to the other “a version of a non-existent picture from the era of its setting” that “often feels phony”. Both are describing the film Burns says he set out to make, and I count that for the rule.
Four o’clock, and a tent
The casting agency in Cork went looking for more than a thousand people to draw the background from. One of them has written about it: the alarm at four, two and a half hours of road each way, then wardrobe, hair and makeup, a large tent to wait in and buses out to the locations. Ages ran from 18 to 70 and many had never stood on a set. Four in the morning for a day in the background, quand même, and they came.
In France it is the first assistant who directs the figuration, and I have always judged an AD department by what it does with first-timers before sunrise. This one formed them up. “Each morning, Aaron greeted us as we passed in the military formation the ADs had organised,” the extra writes, and credits one Sheena Kelly with knowing where everyone had to be “right down to the last second”. On a war film that is rehearsal as much as crowd control: people who fell in as a unit at call arrive on the set already moving as one.
The money and the room
The credits carry six producers and at least ten executive producers, the film had the support of the Screen Ireland Nationwide Fund, and I have never seen a credit block of that length on a picture paid for with one cheque. Nor have I met public money that had no opinion about where the crew is hired, so I read ten, ten and 200 as arithmetic as well as taste.
One of the executive producers is Stewart’s daughter, Kelly Stewart-Harcourt. Her own first thought about a biopic was that it would be “boring because he had a scandal-free life”, and I have seen the same doubt from people waiting for the film, who grant the actor the cadence and wonder whether a decent man can fill two hours. One of them got the short answer from another: look up his military career. Stewart-Harcourt brought the long one, her father’s flight logbook, with its pencilled note: “Ships marked asterisk did not return”.
Burns & Co. went out with Fathom in the US on 6 November, two days after a Dallas premiere with a military colour guard and a B-24 Liberator flying overhead, and veterans, serving military, first responders and their families are offered free tickets. One veteran wrote that no free seats were listed anywhere near them and that they would buy a ticket anyway. Both halves of that sentence belong in the distributor’s report.
What I would take from it
If I were prepping a period film at this size tomorrow, I would start the repérage with the one thing the script needs that scenery cannot give. For Burns it was a studio that could play a studio, and the fields, the beach and the great house were found around it. Then I would hire my heads of department where that thing stands. Ten, ten and 200.
To the location managers: what is the most you have asked one county to play, and which double gave you away?
Where my own notes ran thin, the Irish Examiner’s visit to the set, IFTN, Variety, Aaron Burns’s conversation with Erin Underwood, an extra’s account on CastMe and the notices at Mark Reviews Movies and Today’s Christian Entertainment filled the gaps.