I will only talk about the rooms where they sing. Heartland, which Shana Feste wrote and directed for Netflix, is sold as a mystery: Misty Jones, a retired country star, comes back to Nashville after 20 years because her niece, a rising singer, has vanished. The mystery is the weaker half. Its plot is overstuffed, its early turn announces itself a long way off, and the notices have itemised both. I have nothing to add to that column. What holds me is that the same film, under the same director and the same cinematographer, contains a second film that works, and that the border between the two runs along the lip of the stage.
Five minutes of props
Start before the first song. The film opens on Misty weeping in the dark beside a mound of dirt, a shovel nearby. Within five minutes we have had the stranger picked up at a bar almost without a word, the beer bottle on the nightstand, the joint in the bathroom, and a Grammy kept in an empty fridge. That is a character drawn by set dressing and blocking, at the speed of a first verse, and I admire the economy even where the inventory is second-hand. The Grammy is the item that stays. It is blunt, and one insert does what a page of dialogue about her career would do worse.
Jessica Chastain plays her as a woman who, in the actress’s own words, “could be incredibly tender, and then five minutes later, shoot someone’s windows out.” She does shoot them out, early, and the windows belong to a neighbour who killed her dog. By then the film has told you how it means to behave.
Where the fights went
Here is what a thriller audience will count as a defect. There is very little fighting. A neighbour’s windows, a set of slashed tyres, a finger raised to a surveillance camera. The film also holds its violence back until it lands on the villains.
Why does that not sink it? Because Feste has moved the fights into the music. Misty is more violent at the piano than she is with her fists. When Jace, the rising star attached to her niece and played by Ross Lynch, needs putting in his place, she does it by outsinging him. A late revelation is delivered by a character from a stage. The confrontations in this film are sung. Those are also the scenes Feste directs with a sure hand, and one notice says it exactly:
Feste clearly knows how to shoot a musical number and delivers quite a few good ones in “Heartland,” but anything remotely approaching a suspense set piece lacks the visual flexibility needed to be visceral.
I think the reason is mechanical. A song arrives on set with half its découpage already written. It fixes the length of the scene to the bar, it gives the performer a front to play to, and it gives the light a motive, because a stage has a rig and a honky-tonk has a neon sign. Everyone on the floor knows where the scene peaks before the first take. A suspense sequence brings none of that with it. Its geography, its clock and its light have to be built shot by shot, and that is a different prep. I have shot both kinds of day. The song is the easier one to block and the harder one to run, since playback, a crowd and every reset send you back to the top of the track. I would still take it. Feste made Country Strong in this idiom in 2010, and you can tell which days she walked into ready.
A casting problem, solved sideways
Chastain did her own singing, and the reviews split on whether she passes for a legend. The film then stands her beside Jennifer Nettles, who sings for a living, for the title duet, and one reviewer calls it an unfair matchup. Feste does not try to hide the gap. Misty’s singing is asked to be an act of aggression before it is asked to be beautiful, hammered out at the keys, and an actress who “sings fairly sweetly” can play anger inside a song far more safely than she can play twenty years of fame.
Carter Faith, a working singer in her first screen role, is the niece. Channing Wilson, a fixture of the live scene, sings in a dive bar. Garrett Hedlund (subdued, and by one account the best thing in the film) and Norbert Leo Butz (the detective, singled out in the same notice) come off best. John Hawkes is wasted, and Nettles gets one scene worth the trip. I read that as the price of hiring people for the songs and then running short of story for them.
Night makes one city of two
The Nashville on screen is partly Atlanta. The fictional theatre called the Dove is the Fox Theatre in Atlanta, and the hall where the niece performs is the Tabernacle, in the same city. The real Nashville supplies Broadway by night, Layla’s Honky Tonk under another name, and the Bluebird Cafe. Khalid Mohtaseb’s image is dark and neon-tinged, a noir sheen laid over clubs and festival stages, where people trade threats on the way to the stage and smiles once the cameras are on. It suits the genre. I suspect it suits the raccord as well, since night and neon are the simplest way I know to make two cities cut as one.
The cost is paid in the living room. One reviewer found the picture too dark to watch at home, and thought the concert crowds looked digitally rendered. This film has no cinema release, so the home screen is the only screen it will ever have, and an image that dark is the one choice here I would argue against.
The verdict
Heartland works as a music film and fails as a mystery. Feste seems to know which of the two she prefers, since by one account the film ends a song too late. The songs are performed in real rooms by people who sing for a living, and that gives it more flavour than most of what goes straight to a platform. I would send a director to it for one lesson. When your lead cannot win the scene the genre expects, stage the scene she can win.
What it took
Principal photography began on 29 September 2025 at Shadowbox Studios in Atlanta, under the working title HTLD. An earlier report had the shoot at two months, split between Georgia and Tennessee and running to at least 30 November. Two Atlanta halls carried the big performance scenes, and Nashville was kept for night exteriors and its own landmarks. Randall Poster is credited as music supervisor and as a producer. The album runs to 15 tracks and came out the same day as the film, its title song an existing one reworked as a duet.
That producer credit is the part worth copying. A song has to be quoted before prep and pre-recorded before its shoot day, because one does not run playback on a track that does not exist, and the board for a film of this kind gets built around the nights the halls are dark and the singers are off the road. A music supervisor who is also a producer is in the room when those dates are set.
Some of my notes for this one come from the reviews in The Guardian, The A.V. Club, Decider, High on Films, UK Film Review and The MN Movie Man, from Solzy at the Movies on the venues, from What’s on Netflix’s production report, and from what Jessica Chastain told Netflix’s Tudum.