Every setup with the alien in Allen was shot three times. Daley Pearson, who created the film and directed it with Jeffrey Walker, gives the count himself: “we shot with Allen there, without Allen there, and then we shot with blue sticks there as well.” A puppet pass, a clean plate and a reference pass, on a picture he calls “a relatively low-budget, kitchen-sink film”. Three passes are routine for a puppet whose operators stand in the frame. What was never routine is the number of shots they applied to, and one decision set that number, late. I want to put the decisions back in the order they were taken, because the film that reached Netflix on 12 November was priced by the last of them.
Three years of tests, and a goose
The idea is older than Ludo, the Brisbane company that made it. Pearson carried it for more than a decade, and Netflix first developed it as a series of roughly eight episodes before putting it, in his words, “on very polite pause”. He reads the pause the way a producer would: “I assume it was a bit too much money.” The feature was never cut down from the series. He tried the sticky tape, then threw everything out and started again with Sophie Miller.
The creature ran on its own calendar. Pearson designed Allen with Steve Boyle of Formation Effects. The shop works out of Screen Queensland Studios in Brisbane, and the film shot there too. Camera tests began about three years before production. Allen was built first as an animatronic, and after a large test with Netflix the animatronic was dropped. “We built this animatronic like a Howard Hughes thing, the goose will fly. And it didn’t fly.” Pearson’s diagnosis is exact: “He was too fine a character, too small and delicate, and the animatronics made him too severe.”
I have watched a creature that charmed a whole workshop turn stiff on the monitor, and the silence at the combo afterwards lasted a long time. This production went back to hands. Allen became a puppet in the bunraku tradition, 69 centimetres tall, worked by anywhere from two to ten puppeteers, and he was made bigger than first drawn so that a hand could fit up his neck.
The bookshelf plan
Pearson had begun with the old economy of the creature film. “I definitely started out planning we’ll just shoot him hiding behind bookshelves and stuff.” A foot here, an eye behind a fish tank, and the audience does the rest. That plan is cheap for a reason. A puppet seen in pieces appears in few shots and asks for little paint-out.
Then the plan changed. The story could not get past its midpoint, he says, without the alien simply sitting in the living room, so Allen would be shown whole and in broad daylight. He places the decision “almost in pre-production”, and adds that it “could have been very, very, very bad”.
Read that date as a first assistant would. Years of design and testing lay behind the creature, and the way he would be shot was still open a few weeks before the camera rolled. Pearson describes the team in an empty room at that point, trialling a performer who would play Allen for a portable motion-capture system. The system went to the complicated sequences, the kite festival among them, and it put a rough live Allen on the monitor beside T.J. Power, “this sort of early Tomb Raider version”. So the third pass was sometimes blue sticks and sometimes a second actor. Either way the visual effects team was on set for the whole shoot.
A clean plate is a few minutes. A pass with a performer brings its own rehearsal. Those minutes on every shot that carries the creature, in a film that now carries him in the open, make a different board from the bookshelf film’s. I have seen such minutes left off a board, and they came back as added days that somebody had to sign for.
The floor paid as well. The silicone skin was heavy enough to wear the puppeteers out over a long rehearsal, and they worked crammed under a bed or in the waves at Coolum.
What the camera kept for itself
One department declined to send its work down the line. A good part of what Allen does is done to light, up to the tractor beam at the climax, and the DP, Toby Oliver, achieved it on the floor with remotely controlled LED rigs. At the kite festival everything is dead on arrival and comes on piece by piece. “It can all happen in camera,” Oliver says. “We’re not doing that stuff later in visual effects. It’s happening now on set.”
I take his side, and for a line producer’s reasons as much as a cameraman’s. The choice is not free. It costs the rigs, a programmer at the desk and prelight time, and each cue has to repeat across the passes. But light that changes in the take lands on the actors, the set and the silicone at the same instant, and it is bought on the floor, on days already in the budget. Made afterwards, the same effect has to be built on every surface in the frame, shot by shot, in a post already carrying a digital face. On a film whose post was about to grow, the DP kept a whole category of work out of it. The puppet did the same service for the actor. Power: “It was like another actor, another performer in the room.”
The second film
The cost of the daylight decision shows in the post. Alt.VFX, under the supervisor Jordan McInnes, began with small replacements of a face or a hand. The work grew until Allen was mostly a digital character on screen, with the puppet still under him throughout, and it became the largest project in that company’s history. Pearson: “We made a film with a puppet, and then it felt like we were making an animated film for a year and a half afterwards.” He admits that Netflix and Walker understood the scale before he did. In the cut, until the expressions and the voice went in, his title character looked “really boring”.
I think the decision was correct. A creature who hides for a whole film is a trick, and this story needed a friend on the sofa. But the reviewer who finds the result glossy, “almost synthetic”, is describing the price. Pearson wanted a film that “felt handmade, that it had a few cracks and sticky tape on it, and felt warm”, and another notice says the polish flattens the handmade feeling of the best scenes. The sticky tape came off in la post-prod, one replacement at a time.
For anyone prepping a creature picture without a streamer behind it, the work is one sentence, written before the board is drawn. How much of him do we see, in what light, and for how long? The number of creature shots hangs from that sentence, and so do the head count under the puppet, the vendor’s bid and the length of the post. If the answer changes, and here it changed for good reasons, the board is redrawn first and the vendor bids again on the new breakdown, as though the film were a new one. It is. And test the creature on camera before the script leans on him. This production did, three years out, which is why the goose died in a workshop and not on a shooting day.
To the creature shops and the VFX supervisors: when a production tells you late that the puppet will be seen whole and in daylight, what is the first thing you ask them to shoot differently?
I checked a few of the particulars against interviews Daley Pearson gave to What’s on Netflix, The AU Review, Nexus Point News and The Guardian, against What’s on Netflix’s account of the build and a Screen Queensland panel page, and against the notices in The Guardian and ComicBasics.